Data Governance vs Technical Governance: Understanding the Key Differences and Their Importance

In any business, managing and controlling data is critical. But as organizations adopt new technologies, they often come across two terms: data governance and technical governance. While they may seem similar at first glance, they represent two distinct areas of governance that are crucial for operational success. This article unpacks the differences between data governance vs technical governance, how they complement each other, and why getting them right is essential for your organization.

What Is Data Governance?

Data governance is the framework for managing data integrity, availability, and security across an organization. It focuses on the policies, standards, and procedures necessary to ensure data is accurate, secure, and used appropriately. This involves both technical aspects—like data security measures—and organizational aspects—such as assigning roles and responsibilities to ensure data accountability.

Key Components of Data Governance

• Data quality management: Ensuring that data is accurate, complete, and reliable.
• Data security: Protecting data from unauthorized access and breaches.
• Compliance: Ensuring that data management practices meet regulatory requirements (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA).
• Data stewardship: Assigning individuals who are responsible for data management and governance processes.
• Data lineage: Tracking the flow of data across systems and its transformations throughout its lifecycle.

Why Data Governance Is Crucial

Poor data governance can lead to data inconsistencies, inefficiencies, and compliance risks. Without it, organizations can’t trust their data, making it hard to make informed decisions. Additionally, it’s vital for protecting sensitive information and preventing data breaches, which could result in costly fines and reputational damage.

What Is Technical Governance?

While data governance focuses on data itself, technical governance deals with the technology infrastructure that manages data and ensures it is effectively utilized. It encompasses the policies, procedures, and tools needed to manage technology investments, ensure IT systems align with business goals, and prevent technology-related risks.

Key Components of Technical Governance

• IT architecture: Defining and managing the structure of IT systems and their interrelations.
• Software lifecycle management: Overseeing the acquisition, deployment, maintenance, and eventual decommissioning of software applications.
• Security protocols: Ensuring that proper IT security measures are in place to protect data and systems from cyber threats.
• Change management: Establishing processes to manage and control changes in the IT environment without disrupting services.
• Asset management: Keeping track of the technology resources within the organization.

Importance of Technical Governance

Without technical governance, businesses risk over-investing in technology they don’t need, under-investing in critical systems, or failing to keep up with industry standards. Strong technical governance helps prevent these pitfalls by ensuring technology is not only secure and compliant but also aligned with the business’s overall goals.

Data Governance vs Technical Governance: Key Differences

While both types of governance are essential for a business, they serve different purposes. The differences between data governance vs technical governance primarily lie in their focus areas and objectives.

Criteria	Data Governance	Technical Governance
Focus	Data quality, security, and compliance	Technology infrastructure and system management
Main Objective	Ensure data integrity and appropriate use	Ensure IT systems align with business goals
Responsibility	Data stewards, compliance officers	IT managers, CIO, system administrators
Scope	Covers all aspects of data handling	Covers all technology, including software and hardware
Governance Tools	Data dictionaries, metadata management tools	IT management systems, security software
Outcomes	Trustworthy, secure, and compliant data	Effective and optimized technology usage

Practical Example

Consider an e-commerce company managing customer data. The data governance team ensures that customer details, such as name, email, and payment information, are accurate and securely stored according to privacy laws. The technical governance team, on the other hand, ensures that the database infrastructure and software are optimized, secure, and can scale as the business grows.

How Data Governance and Technical Governance Work Together

Although data governance and technical governance operate in different domains, they often overlap and must work together for a business to succeed.

• Data Security: Data governance focuses on protecting sensitive data, but it needs technical governance to ensure IT systems have robust security features, such as encryption and access control.
• Compliance: Regulatory requirements for data handling are part of data governance. However, compliance often depends on the IT infrastructure’s ability to store and process data securely—an aspect covered by technical governance.
• Business Continuity: Data governance ensures the continuity of critical business data, while technical governance ensures that IT systems supporting this data are reliable and available.

Key Challenges in Data Governance vs Technical Governance

Organizations often face challenges when trying to implement data governance and technical governance. Knowing the common roadblocks can help businesses address them before they become serious issues.

Challenges in Data Governance

1. Data Silos: Different departments may maintain separate datasets, leading to inconsistencies and miscommunication.
2. Lack of Ownership: Without clear ownership of data governance, responsibilities can become unclear, leading to poor data management practices.
3. Regulatory Compliance: Keeping up with the ever-changing regulatory landscape is an ongoing challenge, particularly for multinational companies.
4. Data Quality: Ensuring that data remains accurate and up-to-date can be difficult as systems grow more complex.

Challenges in Technical Governance

1. Technology Sprawl: As companies adopt more technology solutions, managing these systems can become overwhelming.
2. Lack of Alignment: IT investments may not always align with business goals, leading to wasted resources and missed opportunities.
3. Security Risks: With new technologies come new vulnerabilities, and IT teams must continuously adapt to keep systems secure.
4. Change Management: Implementing new technologies or processes without disrupting current systems is a common challenge.

Best Practices for Implementing Data Governance and Technical Governance

Implementing a solid framework for both data governance and technical governance requires careful planning and execution. Here are some best practices to follow:

Best Practices for Data Governance

• Create a data governance council: This should include stakeholders from various departments who can oversee and enforce data policies.
• Establish clear data ownership: Assign roles to data stewards who are responsible for managing the quality and security of the data.
• Use data governance tools: Invest in technology that facilitates data lineage tracking, metadata management, and data quality monitoring.
• Regular audits: Conduct regular reviews to ensure data governance policies are being followed and to identify any gaps.
• Educate employees: Everyone in the organization should understand the importance of data governance and their role in ensuring its success.

Best Practices for Technical Governance

• Develop an IT governance framework: Align the IT strategy with business objectives and establish processes for decision-making.
• Prioritize cybersecurity: Implement and maintain security protocols to protect IT systems from internal and external threats.
• Monitor IT assets: Keep track of all hardware and software to ensure they are being used effectively and aren’t creating unnecessary risks.
• Change management processes: Ensure a structured approach to implementing new technologies or making changes to existing systems.
• Invest in training: Equip IT staff with the latest knowledge and skills needed to manage and optimize technology systems.

Key Tools for Data Governance and Technical Governance

Several tools and software solutions can help organizations implement robust data and technical governance frameworks.

Tools for Data Governance

1. Collibra: A data governance platform that helps businesses manage data quality, compliance, and governance processes.
2. Informatica: Provides tools for data management, data quality, and metadata management.
3. Alation: Focuses on data cataloging, making it easier for organizations to find and use trustworthy data.

Tools for Technical Governance

1. ServiceNow ITBM: A platform that helps manage IT investments, resources, and projects in line with business goals.
2. SolarWinds: A set of IT management tools designed for monitoring infrastructure performance, security, and compliance.
3. Splunk: A powerful tool for tracking and analyzing machine-generated data from IT systems.

The Role of Leadership in Data Governance vs Technical Governance

Leadership plays a pivotal role in the success of both data governance and technical governance. Without strong leadership, governance efforts can become fragmented, uncoordinated, or misaligned with the business’s overall goals.

Leadership in Data Governance

In data governance, leadership ensures that data is treated as a strategic asset. Chief Data Officers (CDOs) or equivalent leaders are often tasked with driving data governance initiatives across the organization. Their responsibilities include:

• Setting data governance priorities: Aligning data governance initiatives with business objectives to ensure that the organization leverages data to its full potential.
• Ensuring accountability: Appointing data stewards and assigning ownership across different business units to foster a culture of responsibility regarding data.
• Promoting a data-driven culture: Encouraging data literacy among employees so that they understand the importance of using and protecting data properly.

Leadership in Technical Governance

In contrast, technical governance leadership is typically handled by Chief Information Officers (CIOs) or Chief Technology Officers (CTOs). They focus on how the technology ecosystem supports the business’s operations and growth. Key responsibilities include:

• Ensuring technological alignment with business goals: CIOs and CTOs must regularly review IT systems to ensure they align with the business strategy.
• Promoting innovation: Encouraging the exploration of new technologies that can improve business processes while managing the associated risks.
• Balancing cost with effectiveness: Leaders must ensure that the organization’s IT investments are providing measurable value without unnecessary cost overruns or inefficiencies.

Both sets of leadership roles are essential, as data governance and technical governance require top-down support to be truly effective. Organizations with committed leadership will find it easier to establish policies, monitor performance, and adapt to changing circumstances in both areas of governance.

Measuring the Success of Data Governance vs Technical Governance

Implementing data and technical governance frameworks is just the beginning. Organizations must also measure their success to understand whether their governance initiatives are achieving their intended outcomes. Let’s explore some ways businesses can evaluate their efforts in both domains.

Measuring Data Governance Success

The effectiveness of data governance can be measured through several key performance indicators (KPIs), such as:

• Data quality metrics: Evaluate the accuracy, completeness, and timeliness of your data. Low error rates indicate effective governance.
• Compliance adherence: Are you meeting regulatory requirements like GDPR, HIPAA, or other industry-specific laws? Frequent audits and a lack of penalties indicate success.
• Data usage: Track how well data is being utilized across departments. If data is readily accessible and trusted, it shows that your governance policies are enabling effective data use.
• Incident response times: How quickly can your organization identify and respond to data breaches or inconsistencies? Fast, efficient handling of incidents is a sign of a solid governance structure.

Measuring Technical Governance Success

Technical governance success is typically measured through metrics tied to the performance and security of IT systems. Some indicators include:

• System uptime and reliability: High availability and minimal downtime indicate that your IT infrastructure is well-governed and reliable.
• Cost management: Track whether your organization is staying within budget on IT projects. Cost overruns or underperformance may indicate weaknesses in governance.
• Security posture: Use cybersecurity metrics like the number of incidents, time to resolve security threats, or vulnerability patching rates to assess your technical governance.
• IT project success rates: The number of IT projects completed on time and within scope can reflect how well your organization manages its technical resources.

By regularly tracking these metrics, organizations can continuously improve both data and technical governance processes, ensuring alignment with business goals and fostering long-term success.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the nuances between data governance vs technical governance is essential for building a secure, compliant, and efficient organization. While data governance focuses on managing and securing data, technical governance ensures that the underlying systems that store and process this data are optimized and secure. Both are critical pillars for any modern business, and neglecting one can undermine the success of the other.

By adopting best practices and investing in the right tools, businesses can create governance frameworks that not only protect their data but also ensure that their technology infrastructure supports long-term goals. Prioritizing both data governance and technical governance will set your organization up for sustainable success, mitigating risks, and creating a foundation for growth.

---

FAQs: Data Governance vs Technical Governance

1. Why are both data governance and technical governance necessary?
Both are necessary because data governance ensures the data is trustworthy and compliant, while technical governance ensures the technology managing this data is secure and aligned with business goals.

2. Can data governance work without technical governance?
No, data governance relies on a robust IT infrastructure to ensure data is properly stored, processed, and secured, which is managed through technical governance.

3. Who is responsible for data governance and technical governance?
Data governance is usually managed by data stewards, compliance officers, and business unit leaders, whereas technical governance is typically overseen by the IT department, including system administrators and the CIO.

4. How can a company transition to better data governance?
Transitioning to better data governance starts with leadership buy-in. Companies should form a data governance council, assign data stewards, and establish clear policies for data handling. Investing in the right data governance tools and fostering a culture of data literacy is also crucial.

5. What happens when technical governance fails?
When technical governance fails, businesses are more likely to experience system outages, security breaches, and project failures. This can lead to operational disruptions, financial losses, and damage to the company’s reputation.

6. Can data governance and technical governance be automated?
Certain aspects of both data and technical governance can be automated. For instance, data governance tools can automate data quality checks and lineage tracking, while IT management systems can automatically monitor infrastructure performance and security compliance. However, automation still requires human oversight to handle exceptions and strategic decision-making.

7. What is the difference between data governance and data management?
Data governance sets the framework for managing data, defining who can access data, how it should be used, and ensuring compliance. Data management, on the other hand, refers to the day-to-day processes involved in collecting, storing, and using data. Governance defines the rules; management is the execution.

8. How does cloud computing impact data governance and technical governance?
Cloud computing introduces new challenges for both data and technical governance. For data governance, it’s essential to ensure data privacy and compliance when using cloud services. For technical governance, businesses must manage cloud infrastructure effectively, ensuring security, scalability, and cost-efficiency. Both require updated policies to reflect the decentralized nature of cloud environments.